On a '90s kick. In Utero is such a better album than Nevermind. Steve Albini was much more suited to producing a Nirvana record than Butch Vig. Vig stripped all the punk out of them and made them lifeless.
I particularly like some of the deep cuts from In Utero like this one.
I've been wanting to respond to this post and haven't had time to get my thoughts together sufficiently until now. I have very strong opinions about Nirvana and "grunge" in general which may not jibe with conventional thought.
But first, man, I never understood the Nevermind backlash. That album is incredible, and has a life of it's own. I saw Nirvana at William and Mary Hall, and listened to people smugly proclaim "Bleach was where it's at" after the show, and I'm calling bullshit on all of it. No one bought Bleach and no one would have if Nevermind wasn't such an enormous monster of an album. And without Nevermind, no one would have ever bought or listened to In Utero. I'm not saying Bleach and In Utero are not worthy of a listen. They each have some great songs and a certain sound that Nevermind definitely departed from. But Nevermind gave Nirvana an enormous audience, radio and video exposure on a global scale, and it introduced millions and millions of people to their other material.
And yes, Nevermind is way slicker than anything else Nirvana made, which you can certainly "blame" on Vig. However, it's certainly not thin. Vig produced the 2 biggest records of the "grunge" era, and they sound so completely different it's hard for me to understand why you'd be down on him.
Producing Siamese Dream would have been pretty damn difficult, considering Billy Corgan and the dozens of guitar tracks that were being laid down on each song. But that album, and Nevermind, are both masterpieces for the Pumpkins and for Nirvana and the rest of their albums don't match up in terms of the overall caliber of songs.
In my opinion, Vig produced the 2 most important rock albums of the era, and probably 2 of the top 100 albums of all time. In addition, he produced great albums from Sonic Youth, Garbage AND one of my 90''s guilty pleasures, the band Gumball.
You leave Butch Vig alone